Comments on: Selborne take sting out of Grey College

By: whatever(whatever)

whatever(whatever) — Sat, 14 May 2011 07:22:07 +0000

Well done Selborne……….proud of that effort………..lekker!

By: keo(keo)

keo(keo) — Wed, 11 May 2011 14:12:23 +0000

outstanding effort from Selborne and the results across all age groups are encouraging

By: XV(XV)

XV(XV) — Mon, 09 May 2011 20:47:44 +0000

@Damo(DAmo374)-4: Thanks for that. I just think that its about time the Eastern Cape schools modernised their thinking. The talent in the Eastern Cape is undoubted......with a more professional approach the results will improve and slowly the area will attract more investment etc. Success begets success.

By: SirBeswick(qc-oldboy)

SirBeswick(qc-oldboy) — Mon, 09 May 2011 19:56:28 +0000

Schools in the eastern cape hardly ever use the 22 match day squad system.Grey P.E has 1300+ boys but they still have a starting XV for the day only with their reserves playing for the 2nd XV.Queens,Dale and St.Andrews also apply that system. The bigger Rugby playing schools however e.g Monnas,paul roos,affies etc employ the 22 matchday squad.

By: Damo(DAmo374)

Damo(DAmo374) — Mon, 09 May 2011 19:11:37 +0000

@XV one must remember Selborne only has +-700 boys while Grey College have well over a 1000 Pupils. So Asking for a more professional approach (including 7 players on the bench) will only mean you watering down the quality of rugby at the school. However the focus is slowly shifting towards a more modern approach the school has invested a substantial amount of money in its sporting programme over the past few seasons with the building of a new school gym the hiring of a personal trainer and dietitian, and the full time employment of a physiotherapist. The draw over the past weekend for the 1st XV and the fact that the rest of the games weren’t the normal “cricket scores” is testament to this. Hopefully with a lot of hard work the tides can slowly start too turn, looking forward too seeing more talents in the likes of the Mark Andrew’s, Brent Russells and Andre Vos’s being molded at the school.

By: XV(XV)

XV(XV) — Mon, 09 May 2011 14:11:46 +0000

@Lions_Soutie(Lions_Soutie)-2: the original report said that the game was in Bloemfontein. Hence my first sentence and paragraph. Your argument is a good one but I think that at 1st team school level in SA it seems to be all about results now. And hence why Selborne are handicapping themselves.

By: Lions_Soutie(Lions_Soutie)

Lions_Soutie(Lions_Soutie) — Mon, 09 May 2011 11:40:46 +0000

@XV(XV)-1: Your point is a bit ambiguous, the first time I read it it seemed like you were implying Selbourne had the advantage. You're right, Grey will always have an advantage if they use 7 'full time' reserves but if you ask me that seems a bit much for school boy level. The sport should be more about participation than results.

By: XV(XV)

XV(XV) — Mon, 09 May 2011 08:25:05 +0000

Hey Keo I understand that the Selborne College /Grey College game was played in East London.

Nevertheless what your report does not mention is a fact that absolutely astounds me. Grey College I am told play the game with 15 +7 reserves. Selborne on the other hand do NOT utilise any reserves and only bring on a replacement if a player has to leave the field permanently due to injury……and that player would have played in a previous game (normally from the 2nd team). Can you imagine a professional team doing that? Come on Selborne..wake up and stop giving yourself an unfair handicap. Especially when you play the best team in the country!